Located in Elsberry, Mo
Located seven miles east of Elsberry and two miles north of Hardin, Illinois. The fiery phantom of Diamond Island was first reported in 1888. A group of men curious about the reports of the light went to the island. They were alarmed to see the phantom change from a ball of light to an old man wearing a pair of denim overalls. It simply stood there for a few seconds and disappeared. The ball of light disappeared and vanished into the island. The bizarre happenings continued for a few more months and suddenly ceased altogether. It is also known that a witches coven perform rituals there.